← Back to blog

🗨️ The Socratic Method in Practice: How to Discuss Disagreements

Ask instead of contradict

When someone makes a claim we disagree with, the obvious move is to go straight to the counterarguments. It feels efficient, but it often ends with both sides digging deeper into their trenches. The Socratic method, which I also wrote about in Socrates and Plato: Two Approaches to Wisdom, points to another way. Instead of arguing against the claim, you ask questions that lead the other person to take a closer look at their own view. Here are three simple moves you can use in practice.

1. Ask for an explanation

Do not contradict the claim right away. Ask instead where it comes from. It sounds trivial, but it works: many weak arguments reveal themselves as soon as they have to be put into words, out loud and in full sentences. Along the way the other person often discovers that the reasoning is thinner than they thought. A good question to start with is:

"What makes you think that?"

2. Ask for evidence

Once the claim has been explained, you can ask what it rests on. This puts the burden where it belongs. It is the person making a claim who has to support it, and you do not need to prove the opposite yourself. Your job is simply to ask, calmly and without judgement. For example:

"What evidence have you seen that supports that?"

3. Stick to one point at a time

When an argument starts to wobble, it is human to jump to the next one to escape the discomfort. If you follow along every time, the conversation turns into a chase from topic to topic where nothing gets settled. Instead, gently steer the conversation back to where it started, so you finish the first question before moving on:

"Wait, let's finish the first point first."

Clarity over victory

The Socratic method is not about winning an argument. It is about creating clarity, both for the other person and for yourself, because sometimes it is your own view that does not hold up. When you ask instead of contradicting, you avoid the defensive reactions that so easily arise, and you make room to examine the claim together. That is exactly what Socrates did in the marketplaces of Athens, and it still works.